FR
Resources
Primitive reflexes
Protocol References Model evolution Updates
Scientific traceability · March → September 2026

Model evolution

The PMCHS framework wasn't born finished. This page traces, step by step, what was thought, published, then revised — so the current version of the model never gives the impression of having always existed in this form.

Why this page? A serious scientific theory changes when the data demands it. Rather than hiding these revisions, this page makes them visible: what we thought at each stage, what was published, what changed afterward and why, and the questions that remain open today.
Status note: this page is a first draft reconstructed from Elisabeth Silva's research notes. Dates marked "to be confirmed" need to be checked and made precise before final publication — in particular the exact months of the two model reformulations (repositioning of primitive reflexes, then restructuring around the locus coeruleus).

The timeline

February 2026 Origin

The starting point: a question about sudden infant death

The research begins from a specific question: could mast cells play a role in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)? This initial intuition — a maternal mast cell terrain as a transversal risk factor — becomes the throughline for everything that follows.

April 2026 Published

Preprint 1 — the initial PMCHS framework

Published on Zenodo/OSF (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19816705), after rejections from medRxiv (no institutional affiliation) and PsyArXiv. This first preprint lays out the initial framework: PMCHS as a predominantly maternal epigenetic terrain, centered on the NR3C1/KITLG axis, four mast cell degranulation phenotypes, and the first data from the international survey (N≈423).

What this preprint establishes
  • Predominantly maternal transmission of the terrain (5.4:1 ratio)
  • Mechanistic model centered on the NR3C1/KITLG axis
  • Four degranulation phenotypes: histaminergic, tryptase-dominant, leukotriene-dominant, prostaglandin-dominant
  • Initial mapping of associated comorbidities
June 2026 Published

Preprint 2 — primitive reflexes and neuromotor development

Published on Zenodo/OSF (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20480196). This second preprint formalizes the link between the maternal mast cell terrain, disrupted synaptic pruning via microglial activation, locus coeruleus hyperactivation, and non-integrated primitive reflexes as an early neurodevelopmental marker.

The thesis at this stage
  • Non-integrated primitive reflexes (Moro, Galant, ATNR, TLR) are presented as a trigger for locus coeruleus hyperactivation
  • Hypothesis of neonatal general interoceptive hypoesthesia (HIG) as a third mechanistic pathway toward SIDS
July 2026 Revision

First course change: primitive reflexes repositioned

Revisiting the model, the thesis shifts on a central point: non-integrated primitive reflexes are no longer seen as the origin of locus coeruleus hyperreactivity, but as a downstream consequence, with its own cascade. The origin of the terrain is repositioned toward an early rupture in safety and attachment — for example, unresponded infant distress that "teaches" the infant that adults are unreliable.

Direct consequence: mast cell/immune dysregulation itself stops being seen as a parallel or upstream driver, and becomes a consequence of chronic locus coeruleus hyperreactivity.

What concretely changes
  • Primitive reflexes: from "origin" to "downstream consequence"
  • Origin of the terrain: early safety/attachment rupture, rather than generic perinatal trauma
  • Mast cells/immunity: repositioned as a consequence of the LC, not an independent driver
August 2026 Revision

Second course change: the locus coeruleus as central node

The causal model is restructured around a simpler principle: the locus coeruleus (chronic hyperactivation) becomes the central upstream node, from which several branches of consequences emerge — behavioral regulation mechanisms, immune dysregulation (mast cells), general interoceptive hypoesthesia (HIG), and dissociation/fawning responses. Primitive reflexes remain in the model, but as one downstream branch among others, no longer as the starting point.

What concretely changes
  • A single causal node (LC) rather than several parallel pathways
  • Four branches of consequences identified from this node
  • A more parsimonious model, easier to test and falsify
September 2026 Today

Current state of the model

Preprint 2 is currently under revision (version 5): adding a section on the thoracic postural mechanism (somatic amplification loop), four new references, and correcting orphan citations pointing to a now-retracted Melillo paper.

The current model places the locus coeruleus as the central causal node, with mast cells, HIG, behavioral regulation mechanisms and primitive reflexes as observable consequence branches — rather than independent drivers of the terrain.

Currently open questions

The model keeps evolving. Among the threads currently being explored and not yet formally integrated: the link between May-Thurner syndrome/pelvic venous congestion and lipedema as a regional mast-cell-mediated trigger; the folate/FRAA mechanism in autism; and the exact place of collagen degradation in the model (a consequence of chronic mast cell activity rather than a primary structural defect). These threads will be added to this timeline as they are formalized.

Keep reading